If you’re in the data center business and not familiar with The Uptime Institute’s tier ratings, then you’re probably not a very good data center company.
Their Tier Standards have been working on data center classification and sorting the good data centers from the beefed-up, great ones for over twenty years. But exactly are Data Center Tier Standards and why do they matter so much?
Data center standards exist to evaluate the quality and reliability of a data center’s server hosting ability. The Uptime Institute uses a somewhat mysterious four-tier ranking system as a benchmark for determining the reliability of a data center. This proprietary rating system begins with Tier I data centers, which are basically warehouses with power, and ends with Tier IV data centers, which offer 2N redundant power and cooling in addition to a 99.99% uptime guarantee.
A Tier III data center is concurrently maintainable, allowing for any planned maintenance activity of power and cooling systems to take place without disrupting the operation of computer hardware located in the data center. In terms of redundancy, Tier III offers N+1 availability. Any unplanned activity such as operational errors or spontaneous failures of infrastructure components can still cause an outage. In other words, Tier III isn’t completely fault tolerant. A Tier 4 data center is fault-tolerant, allowing for the occurrence of any unplanned activity while still maintaining operations. Tier 4 facilities have no single points of failure.
The basic concept is that a Tier 4 design requires double the infrastructure of a Tier III design. Note that both Tier III and Tier 4 data center specifications require IT equipment to have dual power inputs to permit maintenance of power distribution components between the UPS and IT equipment
Now that you know a little about what the different data center standards are, let’s dive into a little more detail of the data center tier definitions:
Tier 1 data center requirements are generally utilized by small businesses and feature:
The benefits of a Tier 2 facility include:
Tier 3 data center specifications are utilized by larger businesses and feature:
Tier 4 data center certification typically serve enterprise corporations and provide the following:
Unfortunately, the Uptime Institute has chosen not to fully publish the evaluation criteria for these different data center levels. Few data centers have tier certifications from the Uptime Institute. Only 38 facilities or design documents for facilities have official tier certifications at this point; these are primarily enterprise data centers. The result is that the Uptime Institute’s definitions have been misused by the industry, ignorantly in many cases.
Facility builders, designers and owners have tried to tweak the terminology slightly to give it their own unique flavor. Enterprises should question any Tier IV claims by data center providers because it is difficult to get customers to pay the rates necessary to monetize the level 4 data center investment of roughly double that of a Tier III facility. Tier I Research has established a bi-level data center tiers quality rating system, with the following criteria. Data center tier standards objectify the design features of a particular facility based upon infrastructure design, capacities, functionalities and operational sustainability.
Therefore, we classify our data centers as meeting Tier 3 data center standards.
However, in the summer of 2015, the Uptime Institute has given a bit more detail into how they will rank data centers moving forward.
In July 2015 The Uptime Institute revised their data center standards to try and stop some disreputable data centers from fudging their rankings.
The majority of data centers are given the Tier III ranking, but with a little bit of savviness these ranking documents “could be used to substantiate a data center that is designed to one Tier level and constructed and commissioned to another Tier level.”
Uptime has said:
“This amendment is made in response to increased scrutiny from industry groups, oversight mechanisms, and legal bodies in North America into the validity of Tier Certification of Design Documents in the commercial marketplace.”
What does all of this mean, though?
“Uptime Institute is addressing the concern that a Tier Certification of Design Documents could be used to substantiate a data center that is designed to one Tier level and constructed and commissioned to another Tier level.”
Basically, if your data center ranking was based on design alone, that particular data center won’t be listed on the Uptime Institute’s website and therefore there hopefully won’t be any confusion about the rankings of a particular data center ever again. You can read more about the new ranking system here.
Way back in May of 2015 The Uptime Institute has added Efficient IT to their rankings for data center tier classification. In their press release Cheif Operating Office of The Uptime Institute stated that:
“Uptime Institute Efficient IT is about better use of resources to better enable the business … Uptime Institute Efficient IT Stamp of Approval codifies the management processes and leadership behaviors that ensure sustained cost savings and resource agility.”
Basically what this means is that rather than what they call “prescriptive requirements” like the cooling, power, etc. listed above, the Efficient IT Stamp of Approval is more or less based on how the data center operates day-to-day and what kind of outcomes they are producing based on certain situations.
A data center can be officially stamped for approval by meeting two award levels for Efficient IT:
To be approved, a data center has to already have been entrenched in meeting the Uptime Institute’s integrity standards for industry excellence. The approval stamp lasts for two years upon when another evaluation will be performed and another stamp will be stamped.
To call yourself activated, your data center must be efficiently working towards meeting the standards of excellence. The activated stamp is valid for a year upon when another evaluation will be performed where you can be upgraded to approved, or given another year of activated.
Efficient IT is quite similar to the Management and Operations (M&O) Stamp of Approval the Uptime Institute delivered back in 2011. They love their stamps—and customers love to see that a data center has these stamps.